Mens turbataA history of the troubled mind

Theory · Antiquity–19th century

Demonic possession and its critics

Many cultures have explained fits, voices and despair as the work of spirits. How Europeans argued over possession from Hippocrates to Charcot, and why the story that medicine simply defeated superstition is too simple.

Saint Benedict driving out a demon by prayer, engraving (Wellcome Collection).
Saint Benedict driving out a demon by prayer, engraving (Wellcome Collection). Unknown author. Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0.

Around 1600 a young Frenchwoman, Marthe Brossier, drew crowds as a demoniac, with convulsions, contortions and a roaring voice. Three physicians, Marescot, Riolan and Duret, were asked to examine her. Their verdict, as Esquirol recalled it more than two centuries later, fitted into five Latin words: nihil a daemone; multa ficta, a morbo pauca, "nothing from the devil; many things feigned; few things from disease"3. It is a neat summary of one side of a very long argument. For as long as people have suffered fits, voices, sudden rages and deep despair, some have blamed spirits and others have looked for causes in the body; and for most of that time many people, physicians included, held both views at once.

Ancient voices

The earliest European statement of the medical side is the Hippocratic treatise On the Sacred Disease, written around 400 BCE about epilepsy, which Greeks attributed to the gods. Its author would have none of it:

it appears to me to be nowise more divine nor more sacred than other diseases, but has a natural cause from which it originates like other affections.1

Quotation checked against the 1849 text

He went further, accusing the "conjurors, purificators, mountebanks, and charlatans" who treated the disease with purifications and incantations of using divinity "as a pretext and screen of their own inability to afford any assistance"1. He located madness in the brain and its humours, not in the heavens1. Belief in possession was not so easily dismissed. The Gospels' accounts of Jesus casting out demons gave Christian Europe a powerful model of possession and its cure by exorcism in his name12.

Possession in the Christian centuries

It is a modern myth that medieval Europeans saw all madness as demonic. Physicians trained in Galen explained most mental disorder by humours, injuries and fevers, and the historians Simon Kemp and Kevin Williams found that over the medieval and early modern periods the range of disorders attributed to possession actually narrowed, with large individual and cultural differences at any one time5.

What changed in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries was the scale and violence of the witch trials, in which the fits of a supposedly bewitched person could become evidence against a neighbour. Some physicians and lawyers pushed back. Johann Weyer, physician to the Duke of Cleves, argued in De praestigiis daemonum (1563) that most of the women accused of witchcraft were deluded by melancholy, their confessions products of a disordered imagination7. In England the Kentish gentleman Reginald Scot made a similar case in The Discoverie of Witchcraft (1584):

melancholie abounding in their head, and occupieng their braine, hath deprived or rather depraved their judgements, and all their senses: I meane not of coosening witches, but of poore melancholike women, which are themselves deceived.2

Quotation checked against the 1886 text

In London at the start of the seventeenth century the physician Edward Jorden argued in court that the fits of a girl, Mary Glover, which were blamed on a neighbour, Elizabeth Jackson, were a natural disease. He set out his argument the next year in A Briefe Discourse of a Disease Called the Suffocation of the Mother, an early English text on what would later be called hysteria4,8. The court was not persuaded, and Jackson was convicted8. At Loudun in western France in 1634, the possession of a convent of Ursuline nuns ended with the parish priest, Urbain Grandier, convicted of sorcery and burned9.

From exorcist to magnetiser

By the eighteenth century educated opinion had moved, but popular demand for exorcism had not. In the 1770s the Catholic priest Johann Joseph Gassner drew great crowds in southern Germany by commanding devils to depart. In 1775 the Bavarian Academy in Munich invited Franz Anton Mesmer to give his opinion. Mesmer said that Gassner was sincere but that his cures worked by animal magnetism, a natural force; Gassner's career faded, and the historian Henri Ellenberger later placed this confrontation at the birth of modern dynamic psychiatry10.

Possession becomes a symptom

The early psychiatrists absorbed possession into their classifications. Esquirol described "demonomania", the conviction of being possessed or damned, as a form of melancholy, and treated its history as a tale of fear spread by preaching and the stake3. Changing fears, he thought, changed the content of madness:

That man is now in a madhouse, because he fears the police, who would formerly have been burnt because he feared the devil.3

Quotation checked against the 1845 text

In 1887 Jean-Martin Charcot and his pupil Paul Richer published Les Démoniaques dans l'art, which read the contorted figures in paintings of exorcisms as portraits of the hysterical attacks they saw at the Salpêtrière11. For these doctors, the history of possession was the history of medicine slowly recognising its own patients.

Belief in possession did not disappear when psychiatry stopped using it. Kemp and Williams noted its survival in Pentecostal churches, and exorcism is still practised in the Catholic Church and other Christian traditions5,12.

Key dates

  1. c. 400 BCE The Hippocratic On the Sacred Disease denies that epilepsy, or any disease, is sent by the gods.
  2. 1563 Johann Weyer's De praestigiis daemonum argues that many accused witches are deluded melancholic women.
  3. 1584 Reginald Scot's Discoverie of Witchcraft attributes witches' confessions to melancholy and fraud.
  4. 1603 Edward Jorden's Briefe Discourse argues that fits blamed on witchcraft in a London case were a natural disease, 'the suffocation of the mother'.
  5. 1634 After the possession of Ursuline nuns at Loudun, the priest Urbain Grandier is convicted of sorcery and burned.
  6. 1775 Franz Anton Mesmer tells the Munich Academy that the priest Johann Joseph Gassner's exorcisms work by animal magnetism.
  7. 1838 Esquirol's treatise describes 'demonomania' as a form of melancholy.
  8. 1887 Charcot and Paul Richer publish Les Démoniaques dans l'art, reading the possessed of old pictures as hysterical patients.

See the full timeline

Sources

  1. Primary source Hippocratic writers, The Genuine Works of Hippocrates, vol. 2 (trans. Francis Adams): On the Sacred Disease, London: Sydenham Society (1849). Quotations checked against this text.
  2. Primary source Reginald Scot, The Discoverie of Witchcraft (reprint of the 1584 edition, ed. Brinsley Nicholson), London: Elliot Stock (1886). Quotations checked against this text.
  3. Primary source Jean-Étienne Dominique Esquirol, Mental Maladies: A Treatise on Insanity (trans. E. K. Hunt), Philadelphia: Lea and Blanchard (1845). Quotations checked against this text.
  4. Primary source Edward Jorden, A Briefe Discourse of a Disease Called the Suffocation of the Mother, London: John Windet (1603).
  5. Scholarship Simon Kemp and Kevin Williams, Demonic possession and mental disorder in medieval and early modern Europe, Psychological Medicine 17(1): 21–29 (1987).
  6. Scholarship Thomas J. Schoeneman, The role of mental illness in the European witch hunts of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries: an assessment, Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 13(4): 337–351 (1977).
  7. Wikipedia Johann Weyer, Wikipedia (2026).
  8. Wikipedia Edward Jorden, Wikipedia (2026).
  9. Wikipedia Loudun possessions, Wikipedia (2026).
  10. Wikipedia Franz Mesmer, Wikipedia (2026).
  11. Wikipedia Jean-Martin Charcot, Wikipedia (2026).
  12. Wikipedia Exorcism in Christianity, Wikipedia (2026).

Cross-checked with Wikidata Q26155706 and the English Wikipedia article.

Pages that mention Demonic possession and its critics