Old diagnoses
Diagnoses that doctors once used with confidence and that have since been renamed, absorbed or abandoned. Each page explains what the word meant at the time, who described it, what some of those patients might be diagnosed with today (a question historians treat with caution), and why it faded.
c. 400 BCE–1900s
Melancholia
For two thousand years melancholia meant fear and sorrow without cause, blamed on black bile. How physicians from Aretaeus to Kraepelin defined it, and how it became 'depression'.
c. 100 CE–1980
Mania
Mania once meant madness itself: raving, sleepless, sometimes joyful. How the word narrowed from Aretaeus to Kraepelin, and how it became one pole of manic-depressive illness.
1374–1600s
Dancing mania
Outbreaks of compulsive dancing along the Rhine and Moselle between 1374 and the 1500s, blamed on saints and demons, later named a 'mania' by doctors. Their cause is still argued over.
1600s–1800s
Hypochondria and the vapours
Before it meant fear of illness, hypochondria was a real disease of the gut and nerves, the male twin of hysteria and, with the vapours, the fashionable 'English malady' of the 1700s.
1680s–1980
Hysteria
Named for the womb, hysteria became medicine's catch-all for symptoms it could not explain. Its history from Greek texts to Sydenham, Charcot and Freud, and why it was dropped in 1980.
1688–1918
Nostalgia
Coined in 1688 for Swiss soldiers sick with longing for home, nostalgia was a diagnosis that army doctors believed could kill. How it rose, spread through armies, and became a mere feeling.
1810s–1870s
Monomania
Esquirol's monomania described a mind sound in every way but one: a single fixed idea or irresistible impulse. It made alienists expert witnesses, then fell apart under criticism after 1854.
1820s–1920s
Puerperal insanity
The nineteenth century's name for madness after childbirth: common in asylum admissions, thought highly curable, and central to infanticide trials, until doctors decided it was no special disease at all.
1820s–1940s
General paralysis of the insane
The deadliest diagnosis in the Victorian asylum: grandiose delusions, failing speech and paralysis, usually fatal within a few years. In 1913 it was proved to be a late form of syphilis.
1835–1910s
Moral insanity
In 1835 J. C. Prichard named a madness of feeling and conduct with reason intact. Moral insanity reached the Old Bailey, provoked a backlash, and fed the later ideas of 'moral imbecility' and psychopathy.
1851–1860s
Drapetomania
A 'disease' invented in 1851 by the Louisiana physician Samuel Cartwright to explain why enslaved people ran away. It was medicalised racism in defence of slavery, and was mocked even in its own day.
1869–1920s
Neurasthenia
George Beard's 'nervous exhaustion' of 1869 blamed modern life for tired, anxious, aching patients. It became the fashionable diagnosis of the 1880s, faded by 1920, and lived on in China.
1874–present
Catatonia
Named by Karl Kahlbaum in 1874 as a disease of tension and stupor, catatonia was absorbed into dementia praecox and schizophrenia, then rediscovered as a syndrome that crosses many illnesses.
1877–present
Folie à deux
Named in Paris in 1877 by Charles Lasègue and Jules Falret: a delusion passed from one person to another who shares their life. Its classic rules have not survived later study, but the name has.
1890s–1950s
Dementia praecox
Emil Kraepelin's 'early dementia' of the 1890s: a psychosis of youth he thought led to lasting decline. Contested from the start, it was renamed schizophrenia and reshaped twentieth-century psychiatry.
1914–1922
Shell shock
A soldiers' phrase of 1914–15 that became a medical diagnosis, a pension category and a political scandal, before a War Office committee in 1922 called it 'a gross and costly misnomer'.
Then and now
A summary of every diagnosis on the site, in the order it was first described. The "now" column is a historian's hedge, not a diagnosis: why mapping old diagnoses onto new ones is uncertain.
| Diagnosis | In use | What it meant | What it may map to now | Why it faded |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Melancholia | c. 400 BCE–1900s | A chronic disorder, without fever, marked by fear and sorrow out of proportion to any cause, often with one fixed false belief, long blamed on an excess of black bile. | Some people diagnosed with melancholia would probably be diagnosed today with severe depression, but older definitions also took in delusional and other states, so the match is loose. | Between about 1880 and 1920 the word 'depression' displaced it as psychiatry recast low mood as a primary disorder of feeling within Kraepelin's manic-depressive insanity. |
| Mania | c. 100 CE–1980 | From antiquity to about 1850, a chronic, feverless madness of excitement, fury or exaltation, often treated as the general form of insanity; afterwards, increasingly one phase of a recurring illness. | Some patients diagnosed with mania would probably be diagnosed today with bipolar disorder, but others had conditions now classed differently, including infections, delirium and schizophrenia, so the match is uncertain. | As a free-standing diagnosis it was absorbed into Kraepelin's manic-depressive insanity after 1899, and the term 'bipolar disorder' replaced that name from 1980. |
| Dancing mania | 1374–1600s | Epidemics in which groups of people danced for hours or days, often in apparent trance, believed to be sent by a saint's curse or the devil, and treated by pilgrimage, exorcism and, once, by music. | Many historians now read the outbreaks as mass psychogenic illness shaped by fear, hunger and religious belief; others favour ergot poisoning or deliberate religious practice, and the sources are too thin to decide. | Outbreaks became rare after the sixteenth century; the medical label survived in nineteenth-century writing, while 'St Vitus's dance' passed to an unrelated childhood movement disorder. |
| Hypochondria and the vapours | 1600s–1800s | A chronic disorder of digestion, nerves and spirits, felt in the upper abdomen and the mind together, which physicians treated as a real bodily disease and, in men, as the counterpart of hysteria. | Some people described as hypochondriacal or 'vapourish' might today be diagnosed with depression, anxiety or health anxiety; others had digestive or other physical illnesses, so the mapping is uncertain. | During the nineteenth century the word came to mean imagined or exaggerated illness, and the old bodily disease dissolved into 'nervousness', neurasthenia and depression. |
| Hysteria | 1680s–1980 | A disorder, diagnosed mostly but never only in women, in which bodily symptoms such as paralysis, fits, loss of voice or sensation appeared without a detectable physical cause. | Some people once diagnosed with hysteria would probably be diagnosed today with functional neurological (conversion) disorder or a dissociative disorder; others had physical illnesses not yet recognised, so the mapping is uncertain. | Its meaning had become too broad and too pejorative; the American DSM-III of 1980 dropped it and divided its territory among conversion, somatisation and dissociative disorders. |
| Nostalgia | 1688–1918 | A disease of people far from home, especially soldiers, in which longing for home produced low spirits, sleeplessness, loss of appetite, fever and wasting, and was thought sometimes to end in death. | Some soldiers diagnosed with nostalgia might today be described as having depression, anxiety or an adjustment disorder; many recorded deaths probably had other causes such as infection, so the mapping is uncertain. | In the late nineteenth century it was absorbed into melancholia; it vanished from military medicine by the First World War, and from the 1920s the word came to mean a mild, fond longing for the past. |
| Monomania | 1810s–1870s | A partial insanity in which one fixed idea, emotion or impulse was deranged while the rest of the mind appeared to work normally. | Some patients diagnosed with monomania might today be diagnosed with delusional disorder, and its 'instinctive' forms survive in names such as kleptomania and pyromania, but case records rarely fit modern categories, so the mapping is uncertain. | Critics led by Jean-Pierre Falret in 1854 argued that no insanity was truly confined to one idea, and courts had grown hostile to it; by the 1870s it had disappeared from use in Paris hospitals. |
| Puerperal insanity | 1820s–1920s | Any serious mental disorder, usually mania or melancholia, arising in pregnancy, soon after delivery or during nursing, and often blamed on the bodily upheavals of childbirth. | Some of these women would probably now be diagnosed with postpartum psychosis, often linked to bipolar disorder, others with severe depression or with infections and other illnesses after childbirth; the old category mixed them together. | By the 1890s leading asylum doctors argued that childbirth produced no special form of insanity, only ordinary mania or melancholia at a vulnerable time, and the diagnosis left the textbooks in the early twentieth century. |
| General paralysis of the insane | 1820s–1940s | A progressive brain disease of the asylum, mostly in men in mid-life, combining grandiose or other delusions with failing speech, tremor and paralysis, ending in dementia and death. | Most cases were probably what is now called neurosyphilis (general paresis), though historians warn that the nineteenth-century label also caught people with other brain diseases. | Proof of its syphilitic cause (1913), fever therapy (1917) and, decisively, penicillin from the 1940s made it rare in countries with access to treatment. |
| Moral insanity | 1835–1910s | A form of insanity in which a person's feelings, temper, habits and conduct were deranged while their reasoning was intact and they held no delusions. | Some people diagnosed with moral insanity might today be diagnosed with a mood disorder or a personality disorder, but its cases were so varied that historians doubt any single modern equivalent. | Courts and the public turned against it after high-profile acquittals in the 1840s and the Townley case of 1863; by 1900 it was being recast as inherited 'moral imbecility' and, in Germany, 'psychopathic inferiority'. |
| Drapetomania | 1851–1860s | Cartwright's name for the wish of enslaved people to escape, which he presented as a curable disease of the mind caused by masters who were either too familiar or too cruel. | It corresponds to no illness: running away from slavery was a reasoned response to enslavement, and the 'diagnosis' is now studied as an example of scientific racism. | It never had wide medical acceptance outside pro-slavery circles, was ridiculed by Northern critics, and lost its purpose with the abolition of slavery in the United States in 1865. |
| Neurasthenia | 1869–1920s | A depletion of the body's limited 'nerve force', blamed on the pace of modern civilisation, producing fatigue, headache, insomnia, indigestion, anxiety, fears and low spirits in otherwise healthy people. | Some people diagnosed with neurasthenia would probably be diagnosed today with depression or an anxiety disorder, and some with physical illnesses then poorly understood, but the old category was so broad that the mapping is uncertain. | Beard's theory of nerve force was never confirmed, and from about 1900 neurologists split the diagnosis into depression, anxiety neurosis and other categories; by the 1920s it had lost its standing in the West. |
| Catatonia | 1874–present | For Kahlbaum a distinct brain disease passing through melancholy, mania, stupor, confusion and dementia, marked by cramp-like disorders of movement; for Kraepelin a form of dementia praecox. | Catatonia is still diagnosed, but as a syndrome of movement and responsiveness that most often accompanies mood disorders, other psychoses or medical illness; how many historical 'catatonics' had which of these cannot be recovered from the records. | It did not vanish but changed status: from Kahlbaum's disease to a subtype of schizophrenia, and, after studies from the 1970s, back to a cross-diagnostic syndrome recognised separately in DSM-5 (2013) and ICD-11. |
| Folie à deux | 1877–present | A rare form of madness in which a dominant, deluded person gradually imposes a plausible delusion on a weaker companion living in isolation with them, who recovers when the two are separated. | Shared delusions are still described, but modern reviews find that the 'secondary' partner often has their own psychiatric vulnerability and does not always recover on separation; DSM-5 (2013) no longer lists it as a separate disorder. | The name survives, but its nineteenth-century rules were undermined by case reviews, and current classifications fold it into delusional and other psychotic disorders. |
| Dementia praecox | 1890s–1950s | A single disease of the young, uniting hebephrenia, catatonia and paranoid dementia, defined by its expected outcome: a lasting weakening of feeling, will and judgement. | Many of Kraepelin's patients would probably be diagnosed with schizophrenia today, but the boundaries differ, recovery is now known to be common, and some cases may have had neurological or mood disorders that the records cannot settle. | Its gloomy name was contradicted by recoveries, and Eugen Bleuler's broader term 'schizophrenia' (1908) displaced it; American official statistics dropped it in 1952. |
| Shell shock | 1914–1922 | The paralyses, tremors, loss of speech, sleeplessness, nightmares and breakdowns of soldiers in the First World War, at first blamed on the physical concussion of exploding shells. | Some of these men would probably now be diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder, others with functional neurological disorder, depression or, in a minority, brain injury from blast; the records rarely allow a confident choice. | Doctors found that most cases had no shell nearby; the army restricted the term from 1917, and the Southborough Committee recommended in 1922 that it be dropped from official use. |