Mens turbataA history of the troubled mind

A history of psychiatry and its patients

Mens turbata: a history of the troubled mind

mens turbata (Latin): mens, "the mind"; turbata, "troubled, disturbed, thrown into confusion". Roman writers used the phrase for a mind shaken by grief, fear or illness.

How did people explain melancholy, mania and despair, and what did they do to the people who suffered them? This site follows that history from the four humours to the first psychiatric drugs: the diagnoses that came and went, the theories behind them, the treatments (humane, useless and harmful), the asylums, and the people on both sides of the locked door, in their own words wherever possible.

Old diagnoses Timeline Essays

Albrecht Dürer, Melencolia I, engraving, 1514.
Albrecht Dürer, Melencolia I, engraving, 1514. Albrecht Dürer. Wikimedia Commons, CC0.

Old diagnoses

Words doctors once used with confidence: what they meant, who described them, what they may correspond to now, and why they faded.

All 16 diagnoses
c. 400 BCE–1900s Melancholia For two thousand years melancholia meant fear and sorrow without cause, blamed on black bile. How physicians from Aretaeus to Kraepelin defined it, and how it became 'depression'. 1680s–1980 Hysteria Named for the womb, hysteria became medicine's catch-all for symptoms it could not explain. Its history from Greek texts to Sydenham, Charcot and Freud, and why it was dropped in 1980. 1688–1918 Nostalgia Coined in 1688 for Swiss soldiers sick with longing for home, nostalgia was a diagnosis that army doctors believed could kill. How it rose, spread through armies, and became a mere feeling. 1914–1922 Shell shock A soldiers' phrase of 1914–15 that became a medical diagnosis, a pension category and a political scandal, before a War Office committee in 1922 called it 'a gross and costly misnomer'. 1869–1920s Neurasthenia George Beard's 'nervous exhaustion' of 1869 blamed modern life for tired, anxious, aching patients. It became the fashionable diagnosis of the 1880s, faded by 1920, and lived on in China. 1890s–1950s Dementia praecox Emil Kraepelin's 'early dementia' of the 1890s: a psychosis of youth he thought led to lasting decline. Contested from the start, it was renamed schizophrenia and reshaped twentieth-century psychiatry. 1851–1860s Drapetomania A 'disease' invented in 1851 by the Louisiana physician Samuel Cartwright to explain why enslaved people ran away. It was medicalised racism in defence of slavery, and was mocked even in its own day. 1374–1600s Dancing mania Outbreaks of compulsive dancing along the Rhine and Moselle between 1374 and the 1500s, blamed on saints and demons, later named a 'mania' by doctors. Their cause is still argued over.

Treatments

From bloodletting and the rotating chair to moral treatment, insulin coma, lobotomy and chlorpromazine.

All 16 treatments

Places

Bethlem, the town of Geel, Vienna's round tower, the York Retreat, and the institutions that followed.

All 12 places

Theories of the troubled mind

Each explanation of madness carried its own cure. These are the ideas that shaped what was done to patients.

All theories
  1. Antiquity–19th centuryDemonic possession and its criticsSome disturbances of mind and body are caused by a demon or evil spirit that has entered or seized a person, and are to be cured by prayer, exorcism or the punishment of whoever sent it.
  2. c. 400 BCE–1800sThe four humoursHealth is a right balance of four fluids, blood, phlegm, yellow bile and black bile, each hot or cold, wet or dry; disorders of mind and body follow when one is in excess or corrupted, and black bile in particular darkens the mind.
  3. 1770s–1850sAnimal magnetism and mesmerismA subtle universal fluid flows through all bodies; illness, including nervous and mental disorder, comes from obstacles to its flow, and a magnetiser can restore it by passes of the hands, touch and magnetised objects, provoking a healing 'crisis'.
  4. 1796–1850sPhrenologyThe brain is the organ of the mind; the mind is made of distinct faculties, each with its own region of the brain whose size indicates its strength, and the shape of the skull reveals the brain beneath.
  5. 1845–1990The biological turnMental illnesses are diseases of the brain, with causes in its structure, chemistry or inheritance, to be studied by the methods of medicine and treated by physical means.
  6. 1857–1914Degeneration theoryHarmful influences such as alcohol, poisons, poverty, disease or immoral living damage a person's constitution; the damage is inherited and grows worse in each generation, from nervousness to insanity to idiocy and sterility, so that a 'degenerate' family line dies out.
  7. 1883–1970sEugenics and psychiatryMental illness, 'feeble-mindedness', epilepsy and crime are largely inherited, so the health of a population can be improved by encouraging the 'fit' to have children and preventing the 'unfit', through segregation, marriage laws and sterilisation.
  8. 1890s–1980PsychoanalysisMuch of mental life is unconscious; symptoms such as hysterical paralysis, obsessions and anxieties express repressed wishes and memories, often from childhood, and they can be relieved when the patient, through free association and the interpretation of dreams and of the relationship with the analyst, brings that material into awareness.

People

Physicians and reformers, and the patients who wrote back: Nellie Bly, Elizabeth Packard, Clifford Beers and others who described the asylum from inside.

All 28 people
1864–1922 · Journalist Nellie Bly American journalist (1864–1922) who in 1887 feigned insanity to be committed to the women's asylum on Blackwell's Island, New York, and published what she saw as Ten Days in a Mad-House. 1816–1897 · Patient-writer Elizabeth Packard Minister's wife (1816–1897) committed to the Illinois asylum by her husband in 1860 under a law that needed no evidence; found sane by a jury in 1864, she campaigned for decades to change commitment laws. 1876–1943 · Patient-writer Clifford Beers Yale graduate and former patient (1876–1943) whose 1908 memoir A Mind That Found Itself exposed abuse in Connecticut asylums and launched the American mental hygiene movement. 1745–1826 · Physician Philippe Pinel French physician (1745–1826) of Bicêtre and the Salpêtrière whose 1801 Treatise on Insanity made moral treatment a medical doctrine; the famous story of him striking off patients' chains is a later legend. 1802–1887 · Reformer Dorothea Dix Massachusetts campaigner (1802–1887) whose memorials to legislatures, from 1843, helped found some thirty American asylums; her federal land bill was vetoed in 1854, and she ran the Union's army nurses. 1860–1935 · Writer Charlotte Perkins Gilman American writer and reformer (1860–1935) who underwent Silas Weir Mitchell's rest cure in 1887 and turned it into 'The Yellow Wall-Paper' (1892), the best-known patient's story of nervous medicine. 1856–1926 · Psychiatrist Emil Kraepelin German psychiatrist (1856–1926) whose division of the psychoses into dementia praecox and manic-depressive insanity shaped classification for a century; he also championed temperance and racial hygiene. 1745–1811 · Hospital governor Jean-Baptiste Pussin A tanner who came to Bicêtre as a patient, became governor of its ward for insane men, taught Pinel moral treatment and in 1797 replaced the chains there with strait-waistcoats. He died at the Salpêtrière in 1811.

Essays

Longer pieces that follow one question across the centuries.

All essays

A glossary of old terms

131 words that once had precise medical or legal meanings, explained as historical terms: what they meant, when, and what replaced them.

AlienistDementia praecoxFolie circulaireHysteriaLypemaniaMad-doctorMelancholiaMonomaniaMoral treatmentNeurastheniaSpleenVapours

Open the glossary

How this site is made

Every factual claim is cited. Quotations from historical texts are checked word for word against public-domain copies of those texts each time the site is built, and dates for people and places are compared with Wikidata. Where historians disagree (whether Pinel really struck off the chains, what Rosenhan's study showed, what an old diagnosis corresponds to today) the page says so. Methods and sources.

This is history, not medical advice. Words such as "lunatic" or "idiot" appear only as historical terms, in quotation marks, and are explained.