Essay · 1838–1911
The patients who wrote back
From John Perceval in the 1830s to Clifford Beers in 1908, former patients wrote against the asylum. Their first battle was to be believed at all, and what they won was mostly the right to be heard.
The people who ran asylums wrote a great deal about the people inside them: case books, annual reports, textbooks, statistics. The people inside wrote back far less often, and when they did, they met an obstacle that had nothing to do with literary skill. A diagnosis of insanity was, among other things, a judgement that a person's account of the world could not be trusted. Anything a patient said against the asylum could be read as one more symptom.
This essay argues that the patient-writers of the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries are best understood as people fighting that judgement. Their first problem was to be believed at all, and the methods they found for getting round it, from a gentleman's standing to a jury's verdict to a journalist's disguise, shaped what they could achieve. What they changed was mostly procedure: hearings, letters, appeals, inspection. They rarely changed what doctors thought madness was, and they did not speak for everyone the asylum held.
The disqualified witness
Clifford Beers put the difficulty plainly in 1908, after three years in Connecticut institutions (Clifford Beers):
It seems to be an almost universal belief that the statements of insane persons are to be regarded with a degree of suspicion that amounts to disbelief.7
Quotation checked against the 1908 text
Elizabeth Packard had found the same thing from the other side. In her account, her husband told her in 1860 why he meant to have her committed to the Illinois asylum at Jacksonville:
I am doing it so that your opinions need not be believed. I must protect the cause of Christ.4
Quotation checked against the 1867 text
Inside the asylum she watched the trustees make their visits and saw why the women around her said nothing:
They well know, that if they tell the truth to the Trustees respecting what they suffer, either that it will not be believed, or that its expression will be construed into an indication of insanity.3
Quotation checked against the 1868 text
Every writer in this essay faced some version of that trap. Most of them had in fact been unwell, and several said so. Their argument was not that they had never been ill, but that illness did not cancel the right to be heard, and that how they had been treated was a separate question from whether they had been mad.
John Perceval and the gentleman's complaint
The first of them in English, and in some ways the sharpest, was John Thomas Perceval, a son of the prime minister Spencer Perceval, who was assassinated in 1812. By his own account his mind gave way in Dublin around Christmas 1830, in the middle of an intense religious experience; his family placed him in two of the most respected private asylums in England, Edward Long Fox's Brislington House near Bristol and then Ticehurst in Sussex, from which he was discharged in 18341,2. In 1838 he published, anonymously, A Narrative of the Treatment Experienced by a Gentleman, during a State of Mental Derangement; a second volume followed in 1840 under his own name2.
What makes the Narrative unusual is that its complaint is not chiefly about chains or beatings, though he described being kept in a strait-waistcoat and struck. It is about being managed without being spoken to. He was moved without explanation, treated without warning, and never reasoned with:
I was not, however, once addressed by argument, expostulation, or persuasion. The persons round me consulted, directed, chose, ordered, and force was the unica and ultima ratio applied to me.1
Quotation checked against the 1838 text
The historian Nicholas Hervey notes that Perceval was clearly very disturbed when he was admitted, but that this does not invalidate his criticisms, which show how little dialogue there was between doctor and patient even in the best houses2. Perceval's standing helped: he wrote as a gentleman complaining that he had not been treated as one, to readers who shared his assumptions. It also hurt. Lord Shaftesbury, the chairman of the Lunacy Commission and a school contemporary, thought he was telling tales2.
In 1838 another former patient, Richard Paternoster, advertised in The Times for fellow sufferers, and Perceval joined him. At a meeting on 7 July 1845 their circle became the Alleged Lunatics' Friend Society, with Perceval as its leading figure2. The Society was mocked by the press and medical journals, but Hervey shows that it secured clauses in the Lunacy Act of 1845, including the right of a patient to obtain copies of the orders and certificates that had confined them, and that it pressed for decades for a hearing before admission, which became law with the Lunacy Act of 18902. Its members also objected that the new county asylums were taking in people with epilepsy and learning disabilities who did not need to be there (Who got locked up, and why)2.
Elizabeth Packard and the jury
Packard's route to credibility was the court. After three years at Jacksonville she was discharged as incurable in 1863 and confined at home; a habeas corpus petition brought her before a jury at Kankakee, which in January 1864 found her sane after a few minutes' deliberation (Elizabeth Packard)5. A jury's verdict was something a doctor's certificate could not simply override, and she built a career on it. Her books, Marital Power Exemplified (1867) and The Prisoners' Hidden Life (1868), mixed her own story with portraits of the women she had lived among3,4.
The results were legal. Illinois's Act for the Protection of Personal Liberty of 1867 gave everyone accused of insanity a jury trial, ending the provision of 1851 under which a husband's request had been enough to commit a wife; she is credited with influencing 34 bills in state legislatures, and with an 1875 law protecting asylum patients' mail5. The remedy she chose shows her diagnosis of the problem. Packard did not attack psychiatry's ideas about insanity. She attacked the ease with which a person could be declared insane without anyone outside the family and the asylum looking at the evidence.
Writing from inside the asylum
Some patients wrote while still confined, and the asylum itself sometimes published them. At the New York State Lunatic Asylum in Utica, patients produced The Opal from 1850 to 1860: ten volumes and over 3,000 pages of essays, poems, political comment and stories, which by the end of its first year had more than 900 subscribers8. Its writers were mostly educated patients from the best wards, and its tone was mostly cheerful and grateful. The historian Benjamin Reiss reads it as a record of patients performing the self-control that moral treatment required: publication was itself part of the cure, and the asylum needed the journal to win public support8. Discontent surfaced only obliquely, in a writer complaining of being "ruled by the Doctor" who ends in submission8.
The poet John Clare is another kind of case. He went voluntarily to Matthew Allen's private asylum at High Beach in Epping Forest in 1837, walked some 80 miles home in July 1841, and at the end of that year was committed to the Northampton General Lunatic Asylum, where he lived until his death on 20 May 186411. He went on writing there, including the poem "I Am", but his asylum poems are not a protest literature; they show what the asylum could leave intact in a person rather than what it did to them11.
The observer and the patient
Nellie Bly was not a patient. In 1887 the New York World sent her, as "Nellie Brown", to feign madness and get herself committed to the women's asylum on Blackwell's Island6. Her disguise solved the credibility problem by inverting it: a sane reporter could say what a certified woman could not, and readers believed her because she had never been ill. She reported the cold, the food, the brutality of some nurses, and above all the women who seemed to her to be there because they were poor, friendless or unable to speak English6. The method had a cost. It made the testimony of the women themselves secondhand, filtered through someone who could leave after ten days.
Twenty years later Beers went the other way. A Mind That Found Itself (1908) was frankly the story of a man who had been severely ill, with delusions he described in detail, and its authority came partly from that frankness and partly from borrowed credit: the psychologist William James allowed a letter praising it to be printed with the book7. Beers turned his account into an organisation, the Connecticut Society for Mental Hygiene in 1908 and the National Committee for Mental Hygiene in 1909 (Clifford Beers)7. The movement soon passed into the hands of psychiatrists, who steered it from patients' grievances towards prevention.
Fiction, theory and the courts
Charlotte Perkins Gilman chose fiction. "The Yellow Wall-Paper" (1892) drew on her own rest cure under Silas Weir Mitchell in 1887, and in 1913 she explained that she wrote it to save people from being driven mad, adding that she had not had hallucinations herself10. A story could be read by people who would never have accepted a patient's complaint as evidence, and it has outlasted every memoir in this essay.
Daniel Paul Schreber, a senior Saxon judge, used the law and then a book (Daniel Paul Schreber). Held at the Sonnenstein asylum from 1894 and placed under guardianship, he conducted his own case for release and won it in 1902; his Memoirs of My Nervous Illness appeared in 19039,12. Schreber's book shows how a patient's writing could be taken up and turned against its author's purposes. Sigmund Freud, who never met him, used it in 1911 as the basis of a theory of paranoia, and for decades the Memoirs were read as Freud's case rather than Schreber's argument9.
What writing back achieved
Read together, these writers left a clear pattern. The ones who changed laws did so by turning a private complaint into a public procedure that did not depend on their own word. Perceval's Society asked for certificates, hearings and inspection; Packard won juries and the protection of letters; Schreber won in court; Beers built a committee of respectable sponsors2,5,7,9. None of them persuaded psychiatry to accept a patient's account of madness as knowledge, and most did not try.
They also spoke for a narrow group. Perceval was a prime minister's son, Packard a minister's wife, Schreber a judge, Beers a Yale graduate. The poor patients of county and state asylums, who were the great majority (Who got locked up, and why), appear in these books mainly as other people, described by their more articulate neighbours. That is not a reason to discount the writers, but it is a reason to read them as advocates with a case, which is how they presented themselves. Bly's method has had a long afterlife, most famously in the Rosenhan study; the problem Beers named, of the patient as a disqualified witness, has had a longer one.
Key dates
- 1838 John Perceval publishes, anonymously, the first volume of his Narrative of the treatment he received in two English private asylums.
- 7 July 1845 Former patients and their supporters meet in London to form the Alleged Lunatics' Friend Society.
- 1850 Patients at the New York State Lunatic Asylum at Utica begin The Opal, a journal written by patients, which runs until 1860.
- 1867 Illinois passes the Act for the Protection of Personal Liberty after Elizabeth Packard's campaign, giving a jury trial to anyone accused of insanity.
- 1887 Nellie Bly publishes Ten Days in a Mad-House, her account of the women's asylum on Blackwell's Island, where she had herself committed.
- 1902 A Dresden appeal court ends the guardianship of Daniel Paul Schreber, who had argued his own case for release.
- 1908 Clifford Beers publishes A Mind That Found Itself and founds the Connecticut Society for Mental Hygiene.
Sources
- Primary source John Thomas Perceval, A Narrative of the Treatment Experienced by a Gentleman, during a State of Mental Derangement, London: Effingham Wilson (1838). Quotations checked against this text.
- Scholarship Nicholas Hervey, Advocacy or folly: the Alleged Lunatics' Friend Society, 1845–63, Medical History 30(3): 245–275 (1986).
- Primary source E. P. W. Packard, The Prisoners' Hidden Life, or Insane Asylums Unveiled, Chicago: the author (1868). Quotations checked against this text.
- Primary source E. P. W. Packard, Marital Power Exemplified in Mrs. Packard's Trial, and Self-Defence from the Charge of Insanity, Hartford: Case, Lockwood & Brainard (1867). Quotations checked against this text.
- Official Illinois Supreme Court history: Elizabeth Packard and mental health laws, Illinois Courts.
- Primary source Nellie Bly, Ten Days in a Mad-House (1887). Quotations checked against this text.
- Primary source Clifford Whittingham Beers, A Mind That Found Itself: An Autobiography, New York: Longmans, Green (1908). Quotations checked against this text.
- Scholarship Benjamin Reiss, Listening to Patients: The Opal Journal as a Source, Social Welfare History Project, VCU Libraries.
- Reference Zvi Lothane, Schreber, Daniel Paul (1842–1911), International Dictionary of Psychoanalysis, via Encyclopedia.com.
- Primary source Charlotte Perkins Gilman, Why I Wrote The Yellow Wall-Paper, The Forerunner, October 1913 (1913). Quotations checked against this text.
- Wikipedia John Clare, Wikipedia.
- Wikipedia Daniel Paul Schreber, Wikipedia.
Pages that mention The patients who wrote back
- Essay "On being sane in insane places": Rosenhan's study and its challengers
- Essay Can we diagnose the dead?
- Essay Who got locked up, and why
- Person Bertha Pappenheim ("Anna O.")
- Person Charlotte Perkins Gilman
- Person Clifford Beers
- Person Daniel Paul Schreber
- Person Elizabeth Packard
- Person Nellie Bly
- Place The asylum on Blackwell's Island
- Treatment The rest cure