Diagnosis · 1820s–1940s
General paralysis of the insane
The deadliest diagnosis in the Victorian asylum: grandiose delusions, failing speech and paralysis, usually fatal within a few years. In 1913 it was proved to be a late form of syphilis.
For a hundred years the asylum doctor's most dreaded diagnosis was not a melancholy or a mania but a disease of the body that announced itself through the mind. Its patients, mostly men in mid-life, often began with grandiose delusions of wealth or power; their speech thickened, their hands shook, their walk faltered; within a few years most were dead3,9. It was called general paralysis of the insane, and it turned out to be syphilis.
A new disease in the asylum
At Bethlem in 1798 the apothecary John Haslam observed that "paralytic affections" were a more frequent cause of madness than was supposed, that such patients had impeded speech and failing memory, and that very few of them were helped in the hospital4. The decisive description came from Paris. In November 1822 a young intern at the Charenton asylum, Antoine-Laurent Bayle, defended a thesis arguing that a particular madness with progressive paralysis was the outward sign of a chronic inflammation of the arachnoid, a membrane of the brain, which he found thickened and clouded at post-mortem examination1. He described three stages: delusions of grandeur with the first traces of paralysis, then mania, then dementia with general paralysis1,2.
Bayle was claiming something radical: that a form of madness hitherto treated as a disorder of the mind itself was the symptom of a visible lesion1. The most eminent French alienist of the day, Jean-Étienne Esquirol, disagreed. In his collected Mental Maladies he treated paralysis as a grave complication, not a disease:
Paralysis complicates all forms of insanity, whatever may be the character of the delirium.2
Quotation checked against the 1845 text
The picture, as Victorian doctors saw it
By 1892 the disease filled pages of Daniel Hack Tuke's Dictionary of Psychological Medicine. Its article, by the asylum superintendent W. Julius Mickle, defined general paralysis by disorders of movement, "especially obvious in speech", by mental symptoms tending to dementia, and by organic changes in the brain3. It struck men "about four times as often" as women, mostly between 30 and 55, and usually ran its course in one to three years2,3.
Mickle's list of causes shows how a disease can be described minutely without being understood. He blamed alcohol first, then overwork, "emotional strain", ambition and the pressures of city life, and gave syphilis a place in a crowded list:
Cranial injuries, brain contusion, brain concussion, insolation, and syphilis, are, all of them, important in the aetiology of general paralysis.3
Quotation checked against the 1892 text
Treatments followed the theories of congestion and inflammation: Bloodletting, purging and emetics by lancet or leeches, purges, cold to the head, and even opening the skull to relieve pressure, with results "stated to be encouraging"3.
Who it struck
At the Worcestershire county asylum at Powick it was the greatest single cause of death. Between 1852 and 1906 most patients there with the diagnosis were married and aged between 31 and 50, and many women died within two years of admission7. Estimates of its share of admissions vary by place and period; one modern review puts neurosyphilis at roughly 5 to 10 per cent of psychiatric admissions before 19456. Mickle thought lower-class men were most affected, while some modern summaries describe a disease chiefly of middle-class men3,6. The historian Gayle Davis has called the rapid decline and certain death of so many previously able patients one of the greatest tragedies of the asylum7.
Syphilis, spirochaetes and fever
The connection with syphilis was suggested in 1857 by Friedrich Esmarch and Peter Willers Jessen and gained ground slowly, notably through the French syphilologist Alfred Fournier9. Doubt persisted because the interval between infection and madness could be ten to thirty years and because antisyphilitic drugs did not cure it5,9. In 1913 Hideyo Noguchi and J. W. Moore at the Rockefeller Institute reported finding the organism of syphilis, Treponema pallidum, in 12 of 70 brains of patients who had died of the disease at a New York state hospital5.
Proof of cause did not bring a cure. In 1917 the Viennese psychiatrist Julius Wagner-Jauregg injected nine patients with blood from a soldier with malaria, reasoning that high fever might halt the disease; six improved, though four of these later relapsed6. Malaria therapy spread worldwide and won him the Nobel Prize in 1927; a review of 35 studies by 1926 reported full remission in 27.5 per cent of patients6. Penicillin, shown effective against syphilis in 1943, ended the era6.
What it maps to now, and why that is uncertain
Today the condition is called general paresis, a form of neurosyphilis. Untreated syphilis can still cause, years later, "memory problems, personality changes and dementia", and it is treated with antibiotics8.
Most patients given this diagnosis probably had neurosyphilis: the long delay after infection, the preponderance of men and the 1913 brain findings all point that way5,9. The match is not exact. General paralysis was a clinical picture defined before anyone could test for syphilis, and historians such as Jennifer Wallis have cautioned against treating the two as identical: the label might also have captured people with other progressive brain diseases that produced similar signs7. Case notes rarely allow anyone to say which patient had which.
Key dates
- 1798 John Haslam of Bethlem notes that patients whose madness came with paralysis seldom recovered.
- November 1822 Antoine-Laurent Bayle's Paris thesis ties a form of madness with paralysis to chronic inflammation of the brain's membranes.
- 1857 Friedrich Esmarch and Peter Willers Jessen point to syphilis in the histories of patients with general paralysis.
- 1913 Hideyo Noguchi and J. W. Moore find the syphilis organism in the brains of patients with general paralysis.
- 1917 Julius Wagner-Jauregg begins treating general paralysis by infecting patients with malaria.
- 1927 Wagner-Jauregg receives the Nobel Prize for malaria therapy.
- 1943 John Mahoney reports the success of penicillin against syphilis.
Sources
- Primary source Antoine-Laurent-Jessé Bayle, Recherches sur les maladies mentales (thèse), Paris: Didot le jeune (1822).
- Primary source Jean-Étienne Dominique Esquirol, Mental Maladies: A Treatise on Insanity (trans. E. K. Hunt), Philadelphia: Lea and Blanchard (1845). Quotations checked against this text.
- Primary source W. Julius Mickle; ed. Daniel Hack Tuke, General Paralysis of the Insane (in A Dictionary of Psychological Medicine, vol. 1), Philadelphia: P. Blakiston, Son & Co. (1892). Quotations checked against this text.
- Primary source John Haslam, Observations on Insanity, London: F. and C. Rivington (1798).
- Primary source Hideyo Noguchi, J. W. Moore, A demonstration of Treponema pallidum in the brain in cases of general paralysis, Journal of Experimental Medicine 17(2) (1913).
- Scholarship Cynthia J. Tsay, Julius Wagner-Jauregg and the Legacy of Malarial Therapy for the Treatment of General Paresis of the Insane, Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine 86(2) (2013).
- Scholarship Frank Crompton, The most deadly disease of asylumdom: the General Paralysis of Insanity at Powick Lunatic Asylum, Worcestershire, 1852 to 1906, Worcester Medical Museums (2021).
- Official NHS, Syphilis, nhs.uk.
- Wikipedia General paresis of the insane, Wikipedia.
Cross-checked with Wikidata Q63526133 and the English Wikipedia article.
Pages that mention General paralysis of the insane
- Diagnosis Catatonia
- Diagnosis Dementia praecox
- Diagnosis Mania
- Essay Can we diagnose the dead?
- Essay Counting the confined: asylum populations, 1800–2000
- Essay The rise and fall of the asylum
- Essay Who got locked up, and why
- Person Julius Wagner-Jauregg
- Place Bethlem Hospital ("Bedlam")
- Theory Degeneration theory
- Theory The biological turn
- Treatment Malaria therapy
- Treatment Moral treatment